Andrew Po-Chih Hu
Professor Slobod
English 113B
1 May 2012
The Guilt Within Them
In life, because the logical thinking
of the human mind contains a sense of responsibility, when people fail their
responsibility for certain things, guilt is one of the feelings that follows
along. Liability and guilt become coexistent on a daily basis in this world
that we have constructed with regulations and laws. When we all think this
makes our life cruel enough, we never stop and think of the wars that are
happening or have happened, and the responsibility and guilt the soldiers that
are fighting or have fought might have carried and hold on to. In war, fighting
becomes the soldiers’ duties, and that the guilt would haunt them if they fail
their duties is something we, as people who have never been in war, could never
truly experience and understand. War only accentuates their responsibility and
guilt and makes them feel they are living real lives when they are ironically
living surreal lives that most people could not understand. In Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried, liability and
guilt carried by the soldiers is well described by O’Brien; different types of
responsibility and guilt is vividly present bringing us one step closer to what
happened, what they carried, and what they still have to live with.
For the
beginning chapter “The Things They Carried,” O’Brien slowly introduces the
things like weapons, equipment, and personal belongings the soldiers carry with
them, which reflects the characters’ personalities and attitudes towards war. This
slightly shows the responsibility they have as soldiers and the role they play
for others, like the Lieutenant, medic, etc. Then O’Brien shows us the very
first guilt experience in the story that Lieutenant Jimmy Cross has because of
the death of his man, Ted Lavender. Although Lieutenant Cross did not cause
Lavender’s death directly, it is his duty to look after and take care of his
men. But instead of being on his duty, he was daydreaming about his love,
Martha. We learned “him felt shame. He hated himself. He had loved Martha more
than his men, and as consequence Lavender was now dead” because of his lack of concentration
on the war and keeping his men in order and safe (16). Cross’ space out from
the war allows Lavender to take off to pee, and he got shot on his way back;
this consequence definitely brings guilt to Cross, but it also teaches him a
great lesson and gives him a wake up call to make him realize his
responsibility as the leader of the troop. This is the type of guilt people
have when you fail your liability and cause someone else to pay the price,
which always haunts the person. As the story goes on, Lieutenant Cross has to
stop daydreaming about Martha and pay full attention to his men and the war
because Lavender’s death always reminds him to be on duty.
A soldier’s
major duty is to fight and kill, which is an act of responsibility towards
serving and protecting his country, but also an act of creating guilt because
taking away people’s lives is naturally against humanity and immoral, or at
least this is what our civilized society had taught us. In “The Man I Killed,”
O’Brien meticulously tells how the boy he had killed is wounded, then he starts
to imagine how the boy’s life might have been and how the boy “hoped the
Americans would go away. Soon, [the boy] hoped. He kept hoping and hoping,
always, even when he was asleep” (119). O’Brien’s imagination about the boy’s
life has already shown his guilt about killing due to the fact that he had taken
away the chance of the boy to live and put an end to his unknown future. It
might have been a life that was wonderful enough for the boy. O’Brien stared at
the boy, “His jaw was in his throat. His one eye was shut and the other was a
star-shaped hole” (120). This imagery stuck in his brain; O’Brien repeats the
condition of the boy’s dead body several times later on in the story,
demonstrating the idea of fulfilling his duty and building up his guilt that
will haunt him. Maybe it is because this is the first man O’Brien has killed,
so the guilt of killing this particular person is piling up faster than he
thought, and it started to swallow him to the abyss of guilt. O’Brien was
taking everything he sees deep down to his soul as his fellow soldiers told him
to sit down to rest and release himself from the shock and horror. The mixture
of responsibility and guilt was stirring up in his body starting to change him.
O’Brien
illustrates how he has become the victim of guilt to the new medic on the team,
Bobby Jorgenson. When O’Brien got shot along the Song Tra Bong, it took
Jorgenson a long time to get to him to treat his wound, then after he finally
got to O’Brien, he either forgot or did not know about treating the shock, and
“bungled the patch job, and a couple of the weeks later [O’Brien’s] ass started
to rot away. [He] could actually peel off fillets of meat with [his]
fingernail” (181). Because of the comparison of Jorgenson to their former
experienced medic Rat Kiley, O’Brien hated Jorgenson even more due to
Jorgenson’s lack of experience, courage, and skills. We can see how a person
might feel guilty and yet does not tolerate the guilt of others if the person
is the victim. Weeks later, Jorgenson and O’Brien meet up at the Headquarter
Company, and Jorgenson apologized to O’Brien for the bad experience and having
not taken good care of O’Brien as their medic. Jorgenson explains how he “got
all frozen up” because that was his first fight out in the battlefield, and he
was afraid (190). Although Jorgenson has show his guilt and sought forgiveness
from O’Brien, O’Brien just could not get passed the feeling of having to pay
back Jorgenson. This is a great example of how most of the time people can be
harsh on others for the mistakes others make, and hope to be forgiven and be
free from guilt if they are the ones that do things wrong. It is interesting
how this works in our lives and how sometimes we live in ironic moments.
Throughout the
novel Tim O’Brien tries to recreate the sense of responsibility and feeling of
guilt through his well descriptive stories allowing us to experience and try to
understand different types of guilt and the origins of guilt. I think O’Brien
has successfully delivered the issue of responsibility and guilt to the readers
and made us rethink war, soldiers, and the life we are living now. Even tough
their responsibility as soldiers has already ended, the guilt is still within
them.
Work Cited
O'Brien, Tim. The Things They
Carried. Mariner, 2009. Print.